I enjoyed my food so much. I could not finish my shrimp. However, each pasta dish my friends and I got was sub-par. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Usually I take out but they have expanded and there is enough for a good sit down. Very accommodating , great amount of food for the price, highly recommend for any event. We order from Mary's frequently the pizza is always fresh and delicious. meatball and shrimp with mushrooms) were sweet and barely edible. Call ahead for take out because this place is always busy. For about 40 people and 10...kids 1500 dollars with tip. Mary’s Speonk: 190 Montauk Highway • 631.801.6600. I took my granddaughter and my son out to dinner the other night. We also got napkins that almost looked used. This place is a family favorite- we've been coming here for years! Two of the dishes (chicken...meatball and shrimp with mushrooms) were sweet and barely edible. Party room is on the ground level, close to the kitchen.More, I really like their food. I had to keep going up to remind them and they still forgot! When asking for the plastic they normally use for take out, they will not give you it as it is for “Take out only”. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in Singapore. Get quick answers from Mary's Pizza and Pasta staff and past visitors. Yes, this pizza meets the mark! Can a vegetarian person get a good meal at this restaurant? I have to say she made the right decision Mary's Pizza Pasta was very very...good. Mary's is a good place to eat and I will be going back there again, the restaurant is clean, the staff friendly and they do not rush you. kids 1500 dollars with tip. The cannoli and cheesecake were mass-produced awfulness. Is this a place where you pay before receiving your order? When asking for the plastic they normally use for take out, they will not give you it as it is for “Take out only”. Service was great quality was good and we will...be sure to return.More, We were celebrating a Birthday with family and they ordered from Mary’s pizza and pasta. I asked for the check and our waitress say oh you have dessert!! more, Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale, TownePlace Suites Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale. Mary's Pizza and Pasta, Farmingdale: See 21 unbiased reviews of Mary's Pizza and Pasta, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #26 of 139 restaurants in Farmingdale. They moved over to a card board to go box that by the time I got home it had lost its usefulness and I had sauce dripping all over. I know this is a local, favorite hangout, but Farmingdale has many other restaurants that do a much better job. I do not recommend and will never be back!!!More. The pasta fagiole soup was a gloppy, stew-like mess. Most places on main Street you have parking problems. I do not recommend and will never be back!!! I mean it’s ok don’t get me wrong but you wait a bit longer than I’d like it. The food was all good, they do have a beer and wine choice too. While not a fine Italian restaurant, it is definitely a notch or two above your average pizza place. Take home left overs? Party room is on the ground level, close to the kitchen. Their salads and soups have a lot of flavor and they... We really like this place for both a quick and casual sit down, and for take out. Hours: Sun-Thur 11-10 • Fri & Sat: 11-11. I mean it’s ok don’t get me wrong but you wait a bit longer than I’d like it. https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/marys-pizza-and-pasta-346083519 It's just enough if you want a small sandwich. They have a lot of good options. So maybe share a meal if that might be a concern.More, I've had pizza and soup at Mary's before. The pizza was not overly salt which is a plus for us!More, We had parties here before, the service is always good, the set up is nice for about 50 people. They didn't say sorry or give me a discount for the inconvenience. Food, service and portions are outstanding. Money-wise, it was reasonably priced. Local restaurant, easy to get to plenty of free parking. One of the better choices for a party in the area. View Mary's Pizza & Pasta menu, located at 611 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735. They must've added a significant amount of sugar. I enjoyed my food so much. I like my pizza just right. Take home left overs? Why I wrote this...is they service. I'm not from the Farmingdale area so when my granddaughter suggested Mary's I was a little torn. Food was fresh and tasty , parking was convenient. Also this may be a problem for some so I make mention of it. Italian delivered from Mary's Pizza and Pasta at 611 Main St, South Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA I had to take it home also, I couldn't eat another thing. HORRIBLE SERVICE. Mary's is a good place to eat and I will be going back there again, the restaurant is clean, the staff friendly and they do not rush you.More. I know this is a local, favorite hangout, but Farmingdale has many other restaurants that do a much better job. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Not too cheesy and not too saucy YET , crispy! The cannoli and cheesecake were mass-produced awfulness. Delivery & Pickup Options - 89 reviews of Mary's Pizza and Pasta "Okay if you are looking for Brooklyn Pizza, look no further for they have it down pact right to the sesame crust. Waited 2 hours to get a wrap! They moved over to a card board to go box that by the time I got home it had lost its usefulness and I had sauce dripping all over. One of the better choices for a party in the area. Find the closest local pizzerias that deliver on Slice. I had to take it home also, I couldn't eat another thing. Most places on main Street you have parking problems. My husband is a very picky eater when it comes to pizza but he was impressed. Plenty of parking, great job again. This isn't you usual take out Italian fare where you just settle on a slice or hero. They were above average. Friendly and efficient staff. Their to go boxes are horrible. Size of portions allowed us to bring some home for tomorrows lunch. I could not finish my shrimp. The pasta fagiole soup was a gloppy, stew-like mess. Their to go boxes are horrible. Last night I had the misfortune of experiencing their pasta night special.